Site Menu

Home Page

Inventory Home

Payment Options NEW

Inventory Categories

Half Cents (2)

Cents (18)

Two Cents (7)

Three Cent Silver (10)

Three Cent Nickel (2)

Nickels (20)

Half Dimes (3)

Dimes (23)

Twenty Cent Pieces (2)

Quarters (9)

Half Dollars (26)

Dollars (26)

Commemorative (9)

Gold (33)

More Options

View All Items

View NEW Items

Featured Items

Coins on Sale

Special Collections

Inventory Archives

My Legend Account

View Account

Account Log-in

Open New Account

Terms of Use

Contact Legend

Call Us Toll Free


New Inventory (Within 30 Days)


SORT INVENTORY:     By Denomination    By Date     By Price     By Grade

Note: Click on Coin Image for Larger View

Half Cents
Item - 10431
$ 15000.00
PR Half Cents are one of our all time favorite coins. They are obsolete, neat, and are beautiful. When we saw this coin we knew we had to own it-the quality and eye appeal are super high end!

Surprisingly deep, clear, clean (there are a couple of MINT MADE die flakes), and highly reflective mirrors dazzle you from all over. You rarely see earlier copper coins with REAL flashy mirrors like this. Other then a teenie drop of toning, there are NO spots. Both sides are enlivened by a beautiful mix of chocolate brown/pale green/pale gold color that's is absolutely ORIGINAL. Miss Liberty and the details are slightly frosty and have perfect pinpoint sharp strikes. The eye appeal is impressive!

ONLY 30 pieces were ever minted. PCGS 5, NGC 0, CAC 3. The last one to sell in major auction brought $14,950.00 1/2014 Goldberg. Keep in mind, fresh and really GEMMY pieces like this hardly ever appear. We think ANY GEM PROOF priced BELOW $20,000.00 is a steal in today's market place. We think this definitely a great piece to put away or add to your collection, what other coins from 1843 can you buy (or find) in GEM PROOF for UNDER $20,000.00?


Half Cents
Item - 10468
H.01C-$1.00 1856 PCGS 64+-PR67 CA
$ 575000.00
Legend Numismatics is pleased to own and offer one of the most exciting numismatic treasures that exists-a complete SUPERB GEM matched original 1856 Proof Set! Every coin is graded by PCGS and has been CAC approved.

This set has been intact since the day each coin was handpicked at the Mint-in 1856. The set has remained with the sale family until 2000 or so when a major dealer bought the families entire PR Set holdings 1856-1867. Legend was fortunate enough to have acquired the bulk of the sets and placed them immediately into great homes. This set was sold to a collector/investor who held on to it for 3 years. When we were re-offered the set, we immediately turned to Bob Simspon who bought it and 3 others (1857-1859). Now that Mr Simspon is overloaded with coins and is cleaning house, we sold this set along with the others (1857-1859) in our July 2014 Regency sale. This set brought $499,375.00. It is important to note, this set was in all NGC holders-with the Dollar grading PR67 and the Dime grading PR68 (we have the inserts). Of all the sets in that deal, this has always been our favorite.

We actually had $500,000.00 hammer to bid on it. You can not find ANY accurate values for this set. These are coins that have no equals! We can easily see this set selling for $1 million dollars in a strong market. If you seek something completely different-and NOT esoteric-here it is. Its highly unlikely that ANY other GEM PR 1856 sets exist-let alone one in such an incredible state of preservation!

Legend loves matched original proof sets. We would never allow a set like this to be broken up. Its just too great a treasure.

H.01 PCGS PR66RB. CAC. (NGC PR66RB). Amazing everything! Strong mirrors have totally original colors. Every detail is needle sharp and really stands out. The eye appeal is phenomenal!

1C PCGS PR66RB SLANTED 6 CAC. (NGC PR66*RB) WOW! Why is this monster not a PR67? Killer mirrors are more red then brown.

1C FE PCGS PR64+ CAC. (NGC PR65). The ONLY reason we can see as to why this is a 64+-pure spite by PCGS. This coin is perfect!

3CS PCGS PR66 CAC. (NGC PR67 CAMEO). Pristine mirrors do contrast with sharply struck features. the mirrors are super bold! We grade this coin 66+ CA.

H.10 PCGS PR66 CAMEO GOLD CAC (NGC PR67 CAMEO). Deeply mirrored. a just a few die lines probably spooked PCGS. We grade the coin PR67 Cameo.

10C PCGS PR66 CAMEO SM DT CAC. (NGC PR68 CAMEO). Only w/a strong glass can you see some die polishing lines. Awesome mirrors. We grade the coin PR67 CA.

25C PCGS PR67 CAMEO CAC. (NGC PR68 CAMEO). PCGS was clearly spiteful here too! An amazing SUPERB GEM w/deep mirrors! We grade this coin PR67+ Cameo at the very least! 50C PCGS PR66 CAMEO CAC. (NGC PR67 CAMEO). Incredible mirrors are nearly blinding! We fully grade this coin PR67 Cameo.

$1 PCGS PR66+ CAMEO GOLD CAC (NGC PR67 CAMEO). We fought hard w/PCGS about calling it a PR67 Cameo. They had to stick to their guns. they are absolutely wrong here-even CAC backs that up. This is one of the most amazing No Motto PR Dollars that exists-and thats not including the fact it is an 1856!

We can't stress enough the HIGH END qualities each coin has, the matched totally ORIGINAL colors, and how deep and incredibly flashy EVERY coins mirrors are! We rarely see sets in the 1900's anymore with this kind of quality or eye appeal.

Valuation was not a problem for us. Keep in mind, even in PCGS holders, each coin is pretty much still the finest known. A coin like the dollar we easily value at $150,000.00. We know for a fact we could get at least $125,000.00 WHOLESALE for it if we broke the set (maybe more if we really shopped it). Plus, its a PR66+ which even CAC agrees with was harsh (it had been an NGC PR67). Non Camoed PR65's trade for $60,000.00 (we've seen one that is dark and ugly). Here you have a coin that should a PR67 with gorgeous moderate original toning and killer mirrors. Plus, we did figure 5% for the total set value. This set definitely has serious upside potential. Opportunity knocks loud here! Call or email us to discuss how we can help you own this once in a life time set.

Item - 10406
$ 8500.00
The Newcomb # is N-4. This is one of our all time favorite Large Cents. The coin just has a look that we love. The quality is SUPER ULTRA HIGH END. Could PCGS have been any tougher on early Large Cents? NO!

Absolutely pristine surfaces dominate both sides. We used a powerful glass and looked over every inch and found ZERO impairments of any size any where. About 30% GEM ORIGINAL MINT RED is visible-mostly around the devices. The balance of color is a delicate GEM ORIGINAL pale brown. There are ZERO spots or toning dots. Miss Liberty and the details are sharply struck. There is some minor weakness from uneven striking pressure in a few stars. The eye appeal is mind boggling!

PCGS 6, NGC 0, CAC 2. This coin last sold in the Dan Holmes Sale 05/2010 for $5,750.00. We assure you, there are NO other 1834's like this coin! If it were in an MS66RB holder, we'd still be madly in love with it.

Item - 10402
$ 9500.00
Our jaws dropped and locked and we still can't eat! Yes, this coin is that amazing.

A remarkable luster shows off surfaces that are basically perfect. We used a strong glass and covered every inch and found ZERO imperfections. Shockingly about 85% of this coin is GEM ORIGINAL MINT RED. There are some splashes of light brown toning (and a few pinpoint toning dots) scattered around. Miss Liberty and the details are sharply struck. The eye appeal is phenomenal!

PCGS 6, NGC 2, CAC 4 (we believe this coin is represented 2x). PCGS has graded only ONE full RED coin-an MS66+ coin that we sold back in 2011 for $70,000.00 (and the color was funky at best). The only time this coin ever appeared in auction was back in 2009-at the original Naftzger Sale. We bought it out of that sale for $6,037 02/2009 Goldberg. Its been 5 long years hidden away and yes, this coin definitely has appreciated-and deserves it. In a major auction it probably would go for a "runaway" price. We assure you, there is NOTHING else like it!

Item - 10404
$ 14950.00
What we are offering here really should not exist! It is a 174 year old Large Cent in perfect condition! PCGS was a bit too tight with calling this coin a 65RB. The quality is ULTRA HIGH END!

At first glance you see a perfect coin. Then when using a strong glass, you still see a perfect coin. For the life of us, we do not know why this coin is not a MS66RB. The colors are about 50% GEM ORIGINAL MINT RED. There are a few pinpoint toning dots scattered around. Some mellow light brown color is visible too. Miss Liberty and the details are lightly frosted and have crisp full strikes. The eye appeal is like the quality-unbelievable!

PCGS 6, NGC 0, CAC 2. PCGS has graded one higher. This coin last sold in the Naftzger sale (where purchased by Legend) back in 09/2009 for $10,925.00. We assure you, there are few (if any) equals to this magnificent GEM!

Item - 10414
1C 1841 PCGS MS66BN
$ 5500.00
Some how we managed to lose the pedigree. We believe it is a Nafztger coin-it sure looks like one!

No question this coin is an MS66++. Its got a really neat die crack going through all the stars on the obverse. The surfaces are flawless. A moderate luster also shows off the totally original brown with hints of MINT RED color that evenly coats both sides. Miss Liberty and the details are frosty and have crisp full strikes. The eye appeal is spectacular!

PCGS 2, NGC 3, CAC 3 (we're pretty sure this is 2x). PCGS and NGC have graded NONE higher. The last one of these to sell in auction brought $4,994.00 09/2014 Heritage. We think that's a steal.


Item - 10415
$ 87500.00
For sure, this is the grand highlight of our Naftzger Large cent offering! We marvel at how this incredible piece even exists.

This unquestionably is the FINEST 1842 RD. The surfaces are remarkably clean and satiny. You can look for hours and find NO imperfections of ANY size,ANY where. A full booming luster combined with absolute ORIGINAL GEM MINT RED colors make this coin resemble a brand new Lincoln Cent! The colors are stable and there is no sign they are turning. Miss Liberty and the details are frosty and are sharply struck. The eye appeal is beyond anything anyone has ever seen for an GEM RD Large cent from the 1840's! Your jaw will drop and lock while uncontrollable drool runs down your cheek!

PCGS 1, NGC 0, CAC 1. This coin last sold in the Cardinal sale in 01/2013 Heritage. It brought $76,375.00. Back in the original Naftzger sale 09/2009, this coin brought $71,875.00. We never regraded this coin. We can not see how this coin could not MS65+ RD at the very least.

Legend is pleased to be to offer our friends this truly once in life time coin. It will certainly be the highlight of ANY GEM Large Cent Collection!

Item - 10412
1C 1843 PCGS MS66BN Petite HD, SM LT N-15 NAFTZGER
$ 8500.00
There is no such thing as a finer 1843BN 1C! This coin is amazing-typical to the Naftzger pedigree.

Absolutely PERFECT surfaces are smooth and have NO marks. There is a very light planchet impression HIDDEN on the neck-that can only be seen with a strong glass. You will marvel at the surfaces like we did. A strong luster (which does have a full cartwheel effect) shows off totally original shades of GEM MINT RED and beautiful original pale brown. There are NO spots or stains. Miss Liberty and the details are frosty and have full crisp strikes. The eye appeal is awesome!

PCGS 2, NGC 4, CAC 3 (we think this coin is 2x)The last time this coin was in auction was in the original Naftzger sale. We paid $6,612.50 for it 09/2009 Goldberg. There have been NO 1843 66BN for sale in auctions since! That is powerful proof as to this coin rarity!


Item - 10417
1C 1847 PCGS MS66BN
$ 5750.00
A piece that is nearly on par with the legendary Nafztger coins are offering here.

Absolutely FLAWLESS surfaces are the epitome of perfection! We used a powerful glass and found NOTHING what so ever anywhere. A decent luster shows off totally ORIGINAL shades of deeper copper/brown/faded Mint Red colors. There are NO spots or discolorations. Miss Liberty and the details are sharply struck and do standout. The eye appeal is superb!

PCGS 5, NGC 26, CAC 3. NO PCGS CAC piece has ever been sold at auction. In fact , the last PCGS piece to sell was a Naftzger coin back in 2009. We can not stress enough how rare this date and grade are!

Item - 10386
$ 18500.00
What an incredible GEM PROOF! The Mint really knew even 144 years ago how to produce a true forever collector worthy coin! This coin certainly is one. It looks like it was minted yesterday!

Deep mirrors like you'd expect to see on a silver coin from the 1890's cover all of the surfaces. The mirrors are deep, crystal clear, remarkably clean, and have strong reflectivity. There are NO spots or discolorations. The reverse actually has hints of light MINT RED. The obverse is mostly brown with highlights of red. Of course the colors are totally original.. Miss Liberty and the details are needle sharp in strike and have thick frost. The eye appeal is sensational!

Read this carefully: ONLY 7 pieces were minted. PCGS 3, NGC 0, CAC 1. We do think this coin is represented more then once on the PCGS pops. This coin last sold for $14,375.00 in the Holmes sale Goldberg 01/2011. You really can't argue how grossly UNDERvalued a coin like this is-even if all 7 survived and were GEM's. How can they not be at least $25,000.00?? Even an 1848 10C in PR 64 is worth $25,000.00-and that's just a 64!!! If your looking for a neat "put away" piece, here it is. Or, if you have junk or dupes laying around-this is a much better hold for the future!

FIRST PAGE | 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 All | NEXT PAGE >>>>

TERMS: All coins are one-of-a-kind and are subject to prior sale

Copyright © 2014 Legend Numismatics Inc.
All Rights Reserved